After a several solid hours w/ this game, I have no problem believing that it’s the highest rated game of all time.
Super Mario Galaxy highest rated game of all time – Joystiq:
Despite certain reviews that highlight the game’s flaws, Super Mario Galaxy is currently the highest rated game of all time on Game Rankings. The aeronautical plumber surpassed The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time by the skin of his pearly Italian teeth, with an average score of 97.8 percent from 30 reviews to Zelda’s 97.6 percent from 31 reviews.
The game balances difficult gameplay challenges w/ the gratification of short planet-based missions, and just brings so many smiles to my face. If you have a Wii and like Mario, you’re gonna love this.